We have an AudioCodes MP-118 analog gateway and were very close to going live with it with Exchange UM. We had just about everything working, but at the last minute went with VM Pro instead. Here's why:
- Call quality - Analog just flat out wasn't as good as digital.
- Delays - Getting it to work required a lot of DTMF trickery that just wasn't very good and didn't work 100% of the time.
- More delays - Exchange UM requires a pretty beefy server to be responsive, and even with our relatively modern server it would still occasionally take 5 or so seconds to answer a call
- No transfer to VM directly. The VM transfer feature just doesn't exist.
- No Caller ID. IPO doesn't have the ability via DTMF or otherwise to send both the calling number AND the called number when redirecting to Group Voicemail, so none of the UM messages had any incoming numbers.
- Completely unsupported. We were going to be 100% on our own to keep the system up and running. Neither Avaya nor our partner wanted any part in trying to get the configuration running.
In general, it was a lot of work just for the WOW factor of getting the calendar and email read to us over the phone, which basically no one was going to do anyway. The integration with Outlook was very nice, and is significantly better than Avaya IMS, as long as you have an all Outlook 2007 shop, but the benefit just isn't there yet. We decided to go with a trial of VMPro in the hopes that a more direct or supported link would come to be, but I am not sure that is going to happen.