VB.NET or ASP.NET ???

[atruhoo]

We are beginning to develop an application where I work that will require both Windows and Web parts to the app based on the users requirements. The problem we are having is deciding on whether or not to use either Windows or Web for the bulk of the application. Curious what guidelines other developers use when trying to make this decision as well as to what you feel may be the advantages/disadvantages of each. Thanks in advance for your input.

Richard

*Also posted on VB.NET board, but wanted to post here as well in case there are strictly ASP.NET/Web programmers that may not check other board

 

[BoulderBum]

[tt]Have you considered a services oriented architecture? In implementing one, you have the freedom to switch from Windows App to Web App, do both, or even some other interface (via a cell phone or Java app perhaps?).

To get started...

Web:
Advantages:
1. Highly portable, operating system doesn't matter.
All the client needs is the web browser of their choice.
2. No distribution and installation problems.
3. Access the application from anywhere!
Disadvantages:
1. Exposed to the world. Security is probably trickier.
2. You end up paying for extra costs associated with hosting.

Windows:
Advantages:
1. Not limited to the restraints of HTML and Scripts.
Highly flexible in display and functionality.
2. Potentially faster (don't need to download GUI).
Disadvantages:
1. Limited to Windows OS (sort of).
2. Portability issues (will it work with Win XP, 98, 2000, etc.?)[/tt]

 

[atruhoo]

Thanks BoulderBum. Hadn't considered services oriented architecture will have to bring it up in next meeting.