Karl,
Suggesting that I "drop the subject" indictes that you are done, and since you are done that I should be done, as well. I understand and accept your feelings. We, however, have an obligation not only to Shaan (who has not responded since creating an Oracle TAR), but we have an obligation to the many Tek-Tipsters who will read this thread in the future, looking for the most simple, definitive solution to a problem that matches Shaan's problem. Just because Shaan is not asking additional followup questions does not mean that we can leave the thread hanging in ambiguity.
The ambiguity arises from your assertion that "You need to recreate the database," to resurrect an instance versus my assertion that recreating the database is unnecessary provided that the database data files are intact.
If I am a Tek-Tipster with Shaan's problem and I'm looking to this thread for help, I am left with the question, "Do I or Don't I need to recreate a (dummy) database in order to get the (real) database running again?"
It is absolutely true as you said, "You do things your way, I do them mine," but just because you can drive from London to Dover via Edinburgh does not mean we should advocate that for those who want to know the most economical route.
You also muddied the waters when you said, "If you prefer to manually edit the Windows registry instead of having DBCA do it for you, you are certainly welcome to try it." Shaan never had an issue with Windows, Windows registries, or DBCA...you took the thread off into the weeds with those topics, when, in fact,
re-creating a database does not refresh or re-create services, registry entries, or anything else having to do with an Oracle Instance per se. One can modify registry entries and services with a variety of software (including DBCA), doing a "CREATE DATABASE..." is not one of those pieces of software.
The original, central issue in this thread, which you have been silent about, is whether or not one must re-create an extraneous database in Unix in order to bring an intact database back into service. My assertion is that you don't need to go through that hassle. Your assertion is clearly different.
So, I am not looking to embarrass you, Karl, or to demand your surrender on this issue; my intent is to assert the most economical (read "least steps/effort") method to resurrect an instance for an intact database.
If you wish to "drop the subject" at this juncture, then that is certainly your choice. But in any case, my hope is that we have reduced/eliminated any ambiguity.
![[santa] [santa] [santa]](/data/assets/smilies/santa.gif)
Mufasa
(aka Dave of Sandy, Utah, USA)
Do you use
Oracle and live or work in
Utah, USA?
Then click here to join
Utah Oracle Users Group on Tek-Tips.