You can't turn on just SQL Server authentication. Why not - well Microsoft would rather we only used Windows Authentication as it's more secure.
You can delete the group Builtin/Administrators from the logins. Then the only way to use Windows Authentication would be to set that on the individual login (Security>Logins). However, be careful with deleting this login. Let's say you use Windows Authentication and you are also a sysadmin. When you remove that login, you will be denied access (even if you have a separate login).
-SQLBill