to analyze the problem i showed you what i did.
Instead of using one x450e and one X150 i am using two X450 for test purpose.
Here is the detailed picture.
this is the configuration of switch 1.
X450e-24p.31 #
X450e-24p.31 # sh vlan
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Name VID Protocol Addr Flags Proto Ports Vir
tual
Active rou
ter
/Total
----------------------------------------------------------------
-------
client-srv 1001 172.16.80.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /6 VR-D
efault
comm 4092 172.16.64.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /1 VR-D
efault
Default 1 -------------------------------T----- ANY 0 /11 VR-D
efault
Mgmt 4095 172.16.0.40 /27 ----------------- ANY 0 /1 VR-M
gmt
srv_vlan 1005 172.16.32.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /7 VR-D
efault
-------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Flags : (C) EAPS Control vlan, (d) NetLogin Dynamically created VLAN,
(D) VLAN Admin Disabled, (E) ESRP Enabled, (f) IP Forwarding Enabled,
(i) ISIS Enabled, (L) Loopback Enabled, (l) MPLS Enabled,
(m) IPmc Forwarding Enabled,

IP Multinetting Enabled,
(N) Network LogIn vlan, (o) OSPF Enabled, (p) PIM Enabled,
(P) EAPS protected vlan, (r) RIP Enabled,
(T) Member of STP Domain, (V) VPLS Enabled, (v) VRRP Enabled
Total number of Vlan(s) : 5
X450e-24p.32 #
X450e-24p.32 #
X450e-24p.32 # sh vlan
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Name VID Protocol Addr Flags Proto Ports Vir
tual
Active rou
ter
/Total
X450e-24p.32 # en
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
client-srv 1001 172.16.80.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /6 VR-D
X450e-24p.32 # enable ipf
efault
comm 4092 172.16.64.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /1 VR-D
efault
Default 1 -------------------------------T----- ANY 0 /11 VR-D
* X450e-24p.34 #
* X450e-24p.34 # conf ipr add vlan all
* X450e-24p.34 # configure ipr add vlan all
efault
Mgmt 4095 172.16.0.40 /27 ----------------- ANY 0 /1 VR-M
gmt
srv_vlan 1005 172.16.32.254 /20 -
efault
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Flags : (C) EAPS Control vlan, (d) NetLogin Dynamically created VLAN,
* X450e-24p.34 # configure ipr add vlan all
(D) VLAN Admin Disabled, (E) ESRP Enabled, (f) IP Forwarding Enabled,
(i) ISIS Enabled, (L) Loopback Enabled, (l) MPLS Enabled,
(m) IPmc Forwarding Enabled,

IP Multinetting Enabled,
* X450e-24p.35 #
(N) Network LogIn vlan, (o) OSPF Enabled, (p) PIM Enabled,
(P) EAPS protected vlan, (r) RIP Enabled,
(T) Member of STP Domain, (V) VPLS Enabled, (v) VRRP Enabled
Total number of Vlan(s) : 5
X450e-24p.32 # enable iff
^
%% Invalid input detected at '^' marker.
X450e-24p.32 # enable ipforwarding
* X450e-24p.33 # conf ipr add vlan all
^
%% Invalid IP address detected at '^' marker.
* X450e-24p.34 # configure ipr add vlan all
ip-mtu IP Maximum Transmission Unit
ip-security IP Security
iparp ip arp command
ipforwarding Configure IP forwarding behavior
ipmcforwarding Configure IP multicast forwarding parameters
ipmroute IP multicast routing module
iproute IP routing module
* X450e-24p.34 # configure iproute add vlan all
^
* X450e-24p.35 #
%% Invalid IP address detected at '^' marker.
* X450e-24p.35 # configure iproute add ?
blackhole blackhole route
default default route
<ipaddress> Destinati
<ipNetmask> IP address / Netmask
<ipv6Netmask> IPv6 address / IPv6 prefix length
* X450e-24p.35 # configure iproute add ?
* X450e-24p.36 #
blackhole blackhole route
default default route
<ipaddress> Destination address
<ipNetmask> IP address / Netmask
* X450e-24p.36 #
<ipv6Netmask> IPv6 address / IPv6 prefix length
* X450e-24p.35 # configure iproute ?
add Add route
delete Delete a route
ipv4 IPv4 info
ipv6 IPV6 HELP
X450e-24p.38 # ena
priority Route origin priority
sharing Configure settings for equal cost multipath routing
* X450e-24p.35 # configure iproute add vlan all
^
%% Invalid IP address detected at '^' marker.
* X450e-24p.35 # configure iproute add ?
blackhole blackhole route
default default route
<ipaddress> Destination address
<ipNetmask> IP address / Netmask
<ipv6Netmask> IPv6 address / IPv6 prefix length
* X450e-24p.35 # configure iproute add 172.16.128.0/20 172.16.128.254
ERROR: Gateway is not on directly attached subnet
* X450e-24p.36 # configure iproute add 172.16.128.0/20 ?
<gateway> gateway address
* X450e-24p.36 # configure iproute add 172.16.128.0/20 172.16.128.254
ERROR: Gateway is not on directly attached subnet
* X450e-24p.36 # configure iproute add 172.16.128.0/20 172.16.32.254
* X450e-24p.37 # save
The configuration file primary.cfg already exists.
Do you want to save configuration to pri
Saving configuration on master ...... done!
Configuration saved to primary.cfg successfully.
X450e-24p.38 # enable rip
* X450e-24p.39 # save
The configuration file primary.cfg already exists.
Do you want to save configuration to primary.cfg and overwrite it? (y/N) Yes
Saving configuration on master ...... done!
Configuration saved to primary.cfg successfully.
X450e-24p.40 #
X450e-24p.40 # show vlan
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Name VID Protocol Addr Flags Proto Ports Vir
tual
Active rou
ter
/Total
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
client-srv 1001 172.16.80.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /6 VR-D
X450e-24p.41 # show vlan srv
efault
comm 4092 172.16.64.254 /20 -f--------r------ A
efault
Default 1 -------------------------------T----- ANY 0 /11 VR-D
efault
Mgmt 4095 172.16.0.40 /27 ----------------- ANY 0 /1 VR-M
gmt
srv_vlan 1005 172.16.32.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /7 VR-D
efault
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Flags : (C) EAPS Control vlan, (d) NetLogin Dynamically created VLAN,
(D) VLAN Admin Disabled, (E) ESRP Enabled, (f) IP Forwarding Enabled,
(i) ISIS Enabled, (L) Loopback Enabled, (l) MPLS Enabled,
(m) IPmc Forwarding Enabled,

IP Multinetting Enabled,
(N) Network LogIn vlan, (o) OSPF Enabled, (p) PIM Enabled,
(P) EAPS protected vlan, (r) RIP Enabled,
(T) Member of STP Domain, (V) VPLS Enabled, (v) VRRP Enabled
Total number of Vlan(s) : 5
X450e-24p.41 # show vlan ser
^
%% Invalid input detected at '^' marker.
X450e-24p.41 # show vlan "srv_vlan"
VLAN Interface with name srv_vlan cre
Admin State: Enabled Tagging: 802.1Q Tag 1005
Virtual router: VR-Default
Primary IP : 172.16.32.254/20
IPv6: None
STPD: None
Protocol: Match all unfiltered protocols
Loopback: Disabled
NetLogin: Disabled
QosProfile: None configured
Egress Rate Limit Designated Port: None configured
Flood Rate Limit QosProfile: None configured
Ports: 7. (Number
Untag: 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11
Tag: 13g
Flags: (*) Active, (!) Disabled, (g) Load Sharing port
(b) Port blocked on the vlan, (m) Mac-Based port
(a) Egress traffic allowed for NetLogin
(u) Egress traffic unallowed for NetLogin
X450e-24p.42 #
X450e-24p.42 # sh vlan
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Name VID Protocol Addr Flags
tual
Active rou
ter
/Total
X450e-24p.43 # sh srv
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
client-srv 1001 172.16.80.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /6 VR-D
efault
comm 4092 172.16.64.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /1 VR-D
efault
Default 1 -------------------------------T----- AN
efault
Mgmt 4095 172.16.0.40 /27 ----------------- ANY 0 /1 VR-M
gmt
srv_vlan 1005 172.16.32.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /7 VR-D
efault
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Flags : (C) EAPS Control vlan, (d) NetLogin Dynamically created VLAN,
(D) VLAN Admin Disabled, (E) ESRP Enabled, (f) IP Forwarding Enabled,
(i) ISIS Enabled, (L) Loopback Enabled, (l) MPLS Enabled,
(m) IPmc Forwarding Enable
(N) Network LogIn vlan, (o) OSPF Enabled, (p) PIM Enabled,
(P) EAPS protected vlan, (r) RIP Enabled,
X450e-24p.44 # sh cli
(T) Member of STP Domain, (V) VPLS Enabled, (v) VRRP Enabled
Total number of Vlan(s) : 5
X450e-24p.43 # sh "srv_vlan"
VLAN Interface with name srv_vlan created by user
Admin State: Enabled Tagging: 802.1Q Tag 1005
Virtual router: VR-Default
Primary IP : 172.16.32.254/20
IPv6: None
STPD: N
Protocol: Match all unfiltered protocols
Loopback: Disabled
NetLogin: Disabled
QosProfile: None configured
Egress Rate Limit Designated Port: None configured
Flood Rate Limit QosProfile: None configured
Ports: 7. (Number of active ports=0)
Untag: 1, 3, 5, 7, 9, 11
Tag: 13g
X450e-24p.45 # sh com
Flags: (*) Active, (!) Disabled, (g) Load Sharing port
(b) Port blocked on the vlan, (m) Mac-Based port
(a) Egress traffic allowed for NetLogin
(u) Egress traffic unallowed for NetLogin
X450e-24p.44 # sh "client-srv"
VLAN Interface with name client-srv created by user
Admin State: Enabled Tagging: 802.1Q Tag 1001
Virtual router: VR-Default
Primary IP : 172.16.80.254/20
IPv6: None
STPD: None
Protocol: Match all unfiltere
Loopback: Disabled
NetLogin: Disabled
QosProfile: None configured
Egress Rate Limit Designated Port: None configured
Flood Rate Limit QosProfile: None configured
Ports: 6. (Number of active ports=0)
Untag: 2, 4, 6, 8, 10, 12
Flags: (*) Active, (!) Disabled, (g) Load Sharing port
(b) Port blocked on the vlan, (m) Mac-Based port
(a) Egress traffic allo
(u) Egress traffic unallowed for NetLogin
X450e-24p.45 # sh "comm"
VLAN Interface with name comm created by user
Admin State: Enabled Tagging:Untagged (Internal tag 4092)
Virtual router: VR-Default
Primary IP : 172.16.64.254/20
IPv6: None
STPD: None
Protocol: Match all unfiltered protocols
Loopback: Disabled
NetLogin: Disabled
QosProfile: None configured
Egress Rate Limit Designated Port: None configured
Flood Rate Limit QosProfile: None configured
Ports: 1. (Number of active ports=0)
Untag: 15
Flags: (*) Active, (!) Disabled, (g) Load Sharing port
X450e-24p.47 # sh ipr
(b) Port blocked on the vlan, (m) Mac-Based port
(a) Egress traffic allowed for NetLogin
(u) Egress traffic unallowed for NetLogin
X450e-24p.46 # sh rip
RIP Routing : Enable
Split Horizon : Enabled Poison Reverse : Enabled
Triggered Updates: Enabled Aggregation : Enabled
Update Interval : 30 Route Timeout : 180
Garbage Timeout : 120 Router Alert : Disabled
Originate Default: Disabled
Sys Import-Policy: None
Redistribute:
Protocol Status Cost Tag Policy
-----------------------------------------------------------
Direct Disabled 0 0 none
Static Disabled 0 0 none
OSPFIntra Disabl
OSPFInter Disabled 0 0 none
OSPFExt1 Disabled 0 0 none
OSPFExt2 Disabled 0 0 none
E-BGP Disabled 0 0 none
I-BGP Disabled 0 0 none
X450e-24p.47 # sh iproute
Ori Destination Gateway Mtr Flags VLAN Duration
d 172.16.32.0/20 172.16.32.254 1 -------um--- srv_vlan 0d:2h:50m:57
s
s 172.16.32.0/20 172.16.32.254 1 -----S-um--- - 0d:2h:50m:56
s
d 172.16.64.0/20 172.16.64.254 1 -------um--- comm
s
s 172.16.64.0/20 172.16.64.254 1 -----S-um--- - 0d:2h:50m:56
s
d 172.16.80.0/20 172.16.80.254 1 -------um--- client-srv 0d:2h:50m:57
s
s 172.16.80.0/20 172.16.80.254 1 -----S-um--- client-srv 0d:2h:50m:56
s
s 172.16.128.0/20 172.16.32.254 1 -----S-um--- srv_vlan 0d:0h:7m:49s
Origin(Ori): (b) BlackHole, (be) EBGP, (bg) BGP, (bi) IBGP, (bo) BOOTP
(ct) CBT, (d) Direct, (df) DownIF, (dv) DVMRP, (e1) ISISL1Ext
(e2) ISISL2Ext, (h) Hardcod
(mb) MBGP, (mbe) MBGPExt, (mbi) MBGPInter, (mp) MPLS Lsp
(mo) MOSPF (o) OSPF, (o1) OSPFExt1, (o2) OSPFExt2
X450e-24p.48 # sh ipcon
(oa) OSPFIntra, (oe) OSPFAsExt, (or) OSPFInter, (pd) PIM-DM, (ps) PI
M-SM
(r) RIP, (ra) RtAdvrt, (s) Static, (sv) SLB_VIP, (un) UnKnown
(*) Preferred unicast route (@) Preferred multicast route
(#) Preferred unicast and multicast route
Flags: (B) BlackHole, (D) Dynamic, (G) Gateway, (H) Host Route
(L) Matching LDP LSP, (l) Calculated LDP LSP, (m) Multicast
(P) LPM-routing, (R) Modified, (S) Static, (s) Static LSP
(T) Matching RSVP-TE LSP, (t) Calculated RSVP-TE LSP, (u) Unicast, (U) Up
(f) Provided to FIB (c) Compressed Route
Mask distribution:
7 routes at length 20
Route Origin distribution:
3 routes from Direct 4 routes from Static
Total number of routes = 7
Total number of compressed routes = 0
X450e-24p.48 # sh ipconfig
Use Redirects : Disab
IpOption LSRR : Enabled
IpOption SSRR : Enabled
IpOption RR : Enabled
IpOption TS : Enabled
IpOption RA : Enabled
Route Sharing : Disabled
Originated Packets : Don't require ipforwarding
IP Fwding into LSP : Disabled
Max Shared Gateways : Current: 4 Configured: 4
IRDP:
Advertisement Address: 255.255.255.255 Maximum Interval: 600
Minimum Interval: 450 Lifetime: 1800 Preference: 0
VLAN IP Address Flags nSIA
client-srv 172.16.80.254 /20 E-f---MPuRX------- 0
comm 172.16.64.254 /20 E-f---MPuRX------- 0
srv_vlan 172.16.32.254 /20 E-f---MPuRX------- 0
Flags: (A) Address Mask Reply Enabled (B) BOOTP Enabled
(b) Broadcast Forwarding Enabled, (E) Interface Enabled
(f) Forwarding Enabled (g) Ignore IP Broadcast Enabled
Press <SPACE> to continue or <Q> to quit (h) Directed Broadcast Forwarding
by Hardware Enabled
(I) IRDP Advertisement Enabled, (l) Forwarding LPM-routing Enabled
(M) Send Parameter Problem Enabled
(m) Multicast forwarding Enabled,

Multinetted VLAN
(nSIA ) Number of Secondary IP Addresses
(P) Send Port Unreachables Enabled, (R) Send Redirects Enabled
(T) Time Stamp Reply Enabled, (U) Interface Up
(u) Send Unreachables Enabled, (X) Send Time Exceeded Enabled
(v) VRRP Enabled
X450e-24p.49 #
Now the Switch 2.......another X450e.....
X450e-24p.11 # sh vlan
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Name VID Protocol Addr Flags Proto Ports Vir
tual
Active rou
ter
/Total
X450e-24p.12 # show srv
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
client_vlan 1001 172.16.96.254 /20 -f-
efault
comm 4092 172.16.64.253 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /1 VR-D
efault
Default 1 -------------------------------T----- ANY 0 /18 VR-D
efault
Mgmt 4095 172.16.0.41 /27 ----------------- ANY 0 /1 VR-M
gmt
srv_vlan 1005 172.16.128.254 /20 -f--------r------ ANY 0 /2 VR-D
efault
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------
Flags : (C) EAPS Control vlan, (d) NetLogin Dynamically created VLAN,
(D) VLAN Admin Disabled, (E) ESRP Enabled, (f) IP Forwarding Enabled,
(i) ISIS Enabled, (L) Loopback Enabled, (l) MPLS Enabled,
(m) IPmc Forwarding Enabled,

IP Multinetting Enabled,
(N) Network LogIn vlan, (o) OSPF Enabled, (p) PIM Enabled,
(P) EAPS protected vlan, (r) RIP Enabled,
X450e-24p.13 # show client
(T) Member of STP Domain, (V) VPLS Enabled, (v) VRRP Enabled
Total number of Vlan(s) : 5
X450e-24p.12 # show "srv_vlan"
VLAN Interface with name srv_vlan
Admin State: Enabled Tagging: 802.1Q Tag 1005
Virtual router: VR-Default
Primary IP : 172.16.128.254/20
IPv6: None
STPD: None
Protocol: Match all unfiltered protocols
Loopback: Disabled
NetLogin: Disabled
QosProfile: None configured
Egress Rate Limit Designated Port: None configured
Flood Rate Limit QosProfile: None configured
Ports: 2. (Numbe
Untag: 11
Tag: 13g
Flags: (*) Active, (!) Disabled, (g) Load Sharing port
X450e-24p.14 # sh
X450e-24p.14 # show comm
(b) Port blocked on the vlan, (m) Mac-Based port
(a) Egress traffic allowed for NetLogin
(u) Egress traffic unallowed for NetLogin
X450e-24p.13 # show "client_vlan"
VLAN Interface with name client_vlan created by user
Admin State: Enabled Tagging: 802.1Q Tag 1001
Virtual router: VR-Default
Primary IP : 172.16.96.254/20
IPv6: None
STPD: None
Protocol: Match all unfiltered protocols
Loopback: Disabled
NetLogin: Disabled
QosProfile: None configured
Egress Rate Limit Designated Port: None configured
Flood Rate Limit QosProfile: None configured
Ports: 3. (Number of active ports=0)
Untag: 2, 4
Tag:
Flags: (*) Active, (!) Disabled, (g) Load Sharing port
(b) Port blocked on the vlan, (m) Mac-Based port
(a) Egress traffic allowed for NetLogin
(u) Egress traffic unallowed for NetLogin
X450e-24p.14 # show "comm"
VLAN Interface with name comm created by user
Admin State: Enabled Tagging:Untagged (Internal tag 4092)
Virtual router: VR-Default
Primary IP : 172.16.64.253/20
IPv6: None
STPD: None
Protocol: Match all unfiltered protocols
Loopback: Disabled
NetLogin: Disabled
QosProfile: None configured
Egress Rate Limit Designated Port: None configured
Flood Rate Limit QosProfile: None configured
Ports: 1. (Number of active ports=0)
Untag: 15
Flags: (*) Active, (!) Disabled, (g) Load Sharing port
X450e-24p.16 # show rip rou
(b) Port blocked on
(a) Egress traffic allowed for NetLogin
(u) Egress traffic unallowed for NetLogin
X450e-24p.15 # show rip
RIP Routing : Enabled
Split Horizon : Enabled Poison Reverse : Enabled
Triggered Updates: Enabled Aggregation : Disabled
Update Interval : 30 Route Timeout : 180
Garbage Timeout : 120 Router Alert : Disabled
Originate Default: Disabled
Sys Import-Policy: None
X450e-24p.17 # sh
X450e-24p.17 # show i
Redistribute:
Protocol Status Cost Tag Policy
-----------------------------------------------------------
Direct Disabled 0 0 none
Static Disabled 0 0 none
OSPFIntra Disabled 0 0 none
OSPFInter Disabled 0 0 none
OSPFExt1 Disabled 0 0 none
OSPFExt2 Disabled 0 0 none
E-BGP Disabled 0 0 none
I-BGP Disabled 0 0 none
X450e-24p.16 # show rip routes
Ori Destination Peer Mtr State VLAN Age Next-hop
Origin(Ori): (be) EBGP, (bi) IBGP, (d) Direct, (o1) OSPFExt1,
(o2) OSPFExt2, (oe) OSPFAsExt, (or) OSPFInter, (s) Static
(>) active route
(St) route state: C=Changed, D=Deleted, U=Update system import policy pending
Total number of routes matching request: 0
X450e-24p.17 # show iproute
Ori Destination Gateway Mtr Flags VLAN Duration
s 172.16.32.0/20 172.16.128.254 1 -----S-um--- srv_vlan 0d:0h:15m:7s
d 172.16.64.0/20 172.16.64.253 1 -------um---
s
s 172.16.64.0/20 172.16.64.253 1 -----S-um--- - 0d:3h:20m:29
s
s 172.16.64.0/20 172.16.64.254 1 -G---S-um--- - 0d:3h:20m:29
s