Tek-Tips is the largest IT community on the Internet today!
Members share and learn making Tek-Tips Forums the best source of peer-reviewed technical information on the Internet!
-
Congratulations derfloh on being selected by the Tek-Tips community for having the most helpful posts in the forums last week. Way to Go!
Error on BCM50 Rls2.0
- Thread starter bncwesty
- Start date
Without any details from you this is only a guess:
Your BCM50 has a public IP and the IP sets are behind a NAT router. When they register to the BCM, they are registering their PRIVATE IP (likely 192.168.X.Y). The BCM knows that it can't route those IP addresses, so it shoots up an alarm.
Am I close in my guestimate of your setup?
Your BCM50 has a public IP and the IP sets are behind a NAT router. When they register to the BCM, they are registering their PRIVATE IP (likely 192.168.X.Y). The BCM knows that it can't route those IP addresses, so it shoots up an alarm.
Am I close in my guestimate of your setup?
- Thread starter
- #3
Magna - you are close, but i think maybe on the right track. The BCM50 has a private address. The DSL modem/router it is connected to has the public address that the IP phone is pointed to. There is then port forwarding to the BCM50. The IP phone is definately registering with a private IP address from the home network. Since it is a base 50, I can't do any routing from the 50.
I've said it before, I'll say it again.
/STEPS UP ONTO SOAPBOX
Instead of trying to save a few hundred bucks, get a VPN setup and avoid the countless hours f***ing around with port-forwarding, NAT issues, no QoS etc and pulled out hair.
VPN works. Other methods can be dragged kicking and screaming into a functional state.
/steps off soapbox and grabs beer....
/STEPS UP ONTO SOAPBOX
Instead of trying to save a few hundred bucks, get a VPN setup and avoid the countless hours f***ing around with port-forwarding, NAT issues, no QoS etc and pulled out hair.
VPN works. Other methods can be dragged kicking and screaming into a functional state.
/steps off soapbox and grabs beer....
Bncwesty,
I setup a BCM50 with 5 ip2004 at an off site location, I used two Netgear ProSafe VPN firewall routers (FVS114, 129.00 bucks each) between the sites. I used the VPN wizard using the defaults and it worked fine.You must make sure each LAN side has a different subnet, one is 10.10.10.0 the other 192.168.1.1 as an example. If you do not have a static IP address's you can go to dyndns.org and setup an automatic update of your routers IP address( first one is free). The Netgear router, has a feature, that will contact dyndns.org every 29 days and reset the service for another free 30 days of use. Just sign up at dyndns.org. Also Netgear tech support will help you with setup. Be advised that both location existing routers will be removed and the Netgear's will replace them.
I setup a BCM50 with 5 ip2004 at an off site location, I used two Netgear ProSafe VPN firewall routers (FVS114, 129.00 bucks each) between the sites. I used the VPN wizard using the defaults and it worked fine.You must make sure each LAN side has a different subnet, one is 10.10.10.0 the other 192.168.1.1 as an example. If you do not have a static IP address's you can go to dyndns.org and setup an automatic update of your routers IP address( first one is free). The Netgear router, has a feature, that will contact dyndns.org every 29 days and reset the service for another free 30 days of use. Just sign up at dyndns.org. Also Netgear tech support will help you with setup. Be advised that both location existing routers will be removed and the Netgear's will replace them.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Question
- Locked
- Question