I appreciate the response. Yes the two values that I am testing are within the same data set. But when I attempt to apply the case statement i get errors with proper syntax.
I may be constructing the CASE incorrectly. Below is what I have...sorry if it is big
SELECT a.FullName, a.ShortName, a.SchoolYear, a.TestAdministrationDate, a.Score, a.Grade, a.Trait_SN, a.Trait_FN, a.ScoreMinimum, a.ScoreMaximum, a.IsBenchmark,
a.FieldColor, a.Student_FN, a.Student_LN, a.Test_Admin_AssessmentID, a.BenchGoal, b.MonthName, b.WeekOfMonth, (CASE (a.Score - a.BenchGoal) When (< 0) Then 'Red' Else 'Black' End) as Barcolor
FROM (SELECT Test_Admin_Assessment.FullName, Test_Admin_Assessment.ShortName, Test_Admin_Assessment.ModifiedBy, Test_Results.SchoolYear,
Test_Results.TestAdministrationDate, Test_Results_Trait.Score, TD_Assessment_Grade.Grade, TD_Available_Traits.FullName AS Trait_FN,
TD_Available_Traits.ShortName AS Trait_SN, TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category.ScoreMinimum,
TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category.ScoreMaximum, TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category.IsBenchmark,
TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category.FieldColor, Student.Student_FN, Student.Student_LN, Test_Results.Test_Admin_AssessmentID, NULL
AS BenchGoal
FROM Test_Admin_Assessment INNER JOIN
Test_Admin_Trait ON Test_Admin_Assessment.ID = Test_Admin_Trait.Test_Admin_AssessmentID INNER JOIN
Test_Results ON Test_Admin_Assessment.ID = Test_Results.Test_Admin_AssessmentID INNER JOIN
Test_Results_Trait ON Test_Admin_Trait.ID = Test_Results_Trait.Test_Admin_Trait_ID AND
Test_Results.ID = Test_Results_Trait.Test_Results_ID INNER JOIN
TD_Assessment_Grade ON Test_Admin_Assessment.AssessmentGradeID = TD_Assessment_Grade.ID INNER JOIN
TD_Traits ON Test_Admin_Trait.TestedTraitID = TD_Traits.ID AND TD_Assessment_Grade.ID = TD_Traits.AssessmentGradeID INNER JOIN
TD_Available_Traits ON TD_Traits.AvailableTraitID = TD_Available_Traits.ID INNER JOIN
TD_SubTraits ON TD_Traits.ID = TD_SubTraits.TraitID INNER JOIN
TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category ON TD_SubTraits.AvailableSubTraitID = TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category.ID AND
Test_Results_Trait.Score >= TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category.ScoreMinimum AND
Test_Results_Trait.Score <= TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category.ScoreMaximum INNER JOIN
Student ON Test_Results.Student_Number = Student.Student_Number AND Test_Results.SchoolYear = Student.SchoolYear AND
Test_Results.DistrictCode = Student.DistrictCode
WHERE (TD_Available_Traits.ShortName = @trait)) AS a FULL OUTER JOIN
(SELECT DISTINCT MonthName, WeekOfMonth, Date, SchoolYear, Year, Month, StandardDate
FROM dim_Date
WHERE (SchoolYear = @schoolyr)) AS b ON a.TestAdministrationDate = b.Date
UNION
SELECT a_1.FullName, a_1.ShortName, a_1.SchoolYear, a_1.TestAdministrationDate, a_1.Score, a_1.Grade, a_1.Trait_SN, a_1.Trait_FN, a_1.ScoreMinimum,
a_1.ScoreMaximum, a_1.IsBenchmark, a_1.FieldColor, a_1.Student_FN, a_1.Student_LN, a_1.Test_Admin_AssessmentID, a_1.BenchGoal, b_1.MonthName,
b_1.WeekOfMonth
FROM (SELECT Test_Admin_Assessment_1.FullName, Test_Admin_Assessment_1.ShortName, Test_Admin_Assessment_1.ModifiedBy, Test_Results_1.SchoolYear,
Test_Results_1.TestAdministrationDate, Test_Results_Trait_1.Score, TD_Assessment_Grade_1.Grade, TD_Available_Traits_1.FullName AS Trait_FN,
TD_Available_Traits_1.ShortName AS Trait_SN, TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.ScoreMinimum,
TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.ScoreMaximum, TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.IsBenchmark,
TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.FieldColor, Student_1.Student_FN, Student_1.Student_LN, Test_Results_1.Test_Admin_AssessmentID,
MIN(TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.ScoreMinimum) AS BenchGoal
FROM Test_Admin_Assessment AS Test_Admin_Assessment_1 INNER JOIN
Test_Admin_Trait AS Test_Admin_Trait_1 ON Test_Admin_Assessment_1.ID = Test_Admin_Trait_1.Test_Admin_AssessmentID INNER JOIN
Test_Results AS Test_Results_1 ON Test_Admin_Assessment_1.ID = Test_Results_1.Test_Admin_AssessmentID INNER JOIN
Test_Results_Trait AS Test_Results_Trait_1 ON Test_Admin_Trait_1.ID = Test_Results_Trait_1.Test_Admin_Trait_ID AND
Test_Results_1.ID = Test_Results_Trait_1.Test_Results_ID INNER JOIN
TD_Assessment_Grade AS TD_Assessment_Grade_1 ON Test_Admin_Assessment_1.AssessmentGradeID = TD_Assessment_Grade_1.ID INNER JOIN
TD_Traits AS TD_Traits_1 ON Test_Admin_Trait_1.TestedTraitID = TD_Traits_1.ID AND
TD_Assessment_Grade_1.ID = TD_Traits_1.AssessmentGradeID INNER JOIN
TD_Available_Traits AS TD_Available_Traits_1 ON TD_Traits_1.AvailableTraitID = TD_Available_Traits_1.ID INNER JOIN
TD_SubTraits AS TD_SubTraits_1 ON TD_Traits_1.ID = TD_SubTraits_1.TraitID INNER JOIN
TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category AS TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1 ON
TD_SubTraits_1.AvailableSubTraitID = TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.ID AND
Test_Results_Trait_1.Score >= TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.ScoreMinimum AND
Test_Results_Trait_1.Score <= TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.ScoreMaximum INNER JOIN
Student AS Student_1 ON Test_Results_1.Student_Number = Student_1.Student_Number AND Test_Results_1.SchoolYear = Student_1.SchoolYear AND
Test_Results_1.DistrictCode = Student_1.DistrictCode
WHERE (TD_Available_Traits_1.ShortName = @trait) AND (TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.IsBenchmark = 'True')
GROUP BY Test_Admin_Assessment_1.FullName, Test_Admin_Assessment_1.ShortName, Test_Admin_Assessment_1.ModifiedBy, Test_Results_1.SchoolYear,
Test_Results_1.TestAdministrationDate, Test_Results_Trait_1.Score, TD_Assessment_Grade_1.Grade, TD_Available_Traits_1.FullName,
TD_Available_Traits_1.ShortName, TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.ScoreMinimum,
TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.ScoreMaximum, TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.IsBenchmark,
TD_Available_Trait_Score_Sub_Category_1.FieldColor, Student_1.Student_FN, Student_1.Student_LN, Test_Results_1.Test_Admin_AssessmentID)
AS a_1 FULL OUTER JOIN
(SELECT DISTINCT MonthName, WeekOfMonth, Date, SchoolYear, Year, Month, StandardDate
FROM dim_Date AS dim_Date_1
WHERE (SchoolYear = @schoolyr)) AS b_1 ON a_1.TestAdministrationDate = b_1.Date